Was this Terrible Tactical Loss a Victory?

[June 2, 2026]  From the Facebook Page of Bruce Willhoit, we learn that on 31 May 1864 in the American Civil War, the Battle of Cold Harbor began.  It would be General Robert E. Lee’s last large-scale field victory of the war.  But was this terrible tactical loss for Union forces nevertheless a strategic victory?

The Facts:

1. The Battle of Cold Harbor lasted from May 31 through June 12, 1864 and is remembered as one of American history’s bloodiest, most lopsided battles.
2. Cold Harbor was the 3rd major battle between generals Robert E. Lee and Ulysses S. Grant. It marked the grand finale of Grant’s Overland Campaign.
3. The Overland Campaign consisted of a grueling six weeks of near-constant combat in Virginia. It was the deadliest campaign of the entire war making 1864, the bloodiest year of the American Civil War.
4. Before the Battle of Cold Harbor, more than 50,000 of Grant’s soldiers had fallen in less than two months of the Overland Campaign…compared to 33,000 of Lee’s soldiers.
5. General Lee understood the strategic reality of the war and accurately predicted that if Union General Ulysses S. Grant crossed the James River, it would result in a hopeless war of attrition. Lee wrote a definitive dispatch expressing this exact warning: “We must destroy this army of Grant’s before he gets to the James River. If he gets there, it will become a siege, and then it will be a mere question of time.”
6. At Cold Harbor Grant ordered repeated, and ultimately disastrous, frontal assaults against Lee’s deeply entrenched positions.
7. The Battle of Cold Harbor is widely considered one of the most disastrous tactical defeats for General Ulysses S. Grant. The battle cost him more than 12,700 casualties. The fighting was horrendous. On June 3rd alone, 7,000 Americans fell in the first 20 to 30 minutes, as roughly 30,000 to 40,000 Union soldiers charged the entrenched Confederate lines.
8. The night before the deadly attack on June, 3rd many of the Union soldiers knew this battle was going to be their last. Many of these brave men wrote their names and addresses on slips of paper and pinned them to the back of their coats, in hope that their families would find out what became of them. Some of them wrote letters home that began “I died today.”
9. After the fighting on June, 3rd, the Union dead covered more than five acres of ground as thickly as they could be laid. A blood-stained diary, salvaged from the pocket of a dead Union soldier had this final entry written in it: “June 3. Cold Harbor. I was killed.” One Union soldier later said of the battle, “it was not war, it was murder.”
10. After the deadly morning frontal attack, Gen. Grant himself inspected his lines and ordered another attack later in the afternoon. One officer refused, saying “I wouldn’t make that charge if Jesus Christ himself ordered it.”
11. Thousands of Union soldiers were left pinned down and wounded in the “no-man’s land” between the lines following the disastrous June 3 attack. Gen. Grant, unwilling to admit defeat, delayed the process of requesting a formal truce to gather the wounded.
12. Because a formal truce was not agreed upon until June 7, the vast majority of these men succumbed to intense heat, dehydration, and their wounds. When the rescue parties finally went out after four days, not many Federal soldiers were found alive.
13. The Confederates suffered about 1,500 casualties on June 3rd, losing one man to every four fallen Federals. The Union army suffered approximately 6,000 to 7,000 casualties that day.
14. The Battle of Cold Harbor itself left more than 18,000 soldiers killed, wounded, or captured. Union Army: approximately 13,000 casualties. Confederate Army: Roughly 4,500 to 5,000 casualties.
15. Despite the Confederate tactical success, the Battle of Cold Harbor stands out as General Robert E. Lee’s final large-scale, decisive field victory. Grant soon changed his strategy to trap the Confederate army in a siege rather than fighting them in the open.
16. General Ulysses S. Grant faced intense public backlash after the Battle of Cold Harbor, with many in the North labeling him a “fumbling butcher” due to the catastrophic loss of life. The devastating results caused a dramatic drop in morale, severely threatening President Abraham Lincoln’s chances of re-election in the fall of 1864.
17. While Grant’s disastrous frontal assault at Cold Harbor was one of the most ill-advised and costly tactical blunders of the war and despite the backlash, Grant’s Overland Campaign had served its purpose…Lee had lost the initiative.
18. Grant’s Overland Campaign resulted in approximately 85,000 to 95,000 total casualties across both sides. Grant’s Union forces suffered an estimated 55,000 casualties, Lee suffered approximately 30,000 to 35,000 casualties.

“I have always regretted that the last assault at Cold Harbor was ever made….No advantage whatever was gained to compensate for the heavy loss we sustained.” — General Ulysses S. Grant

The Analysis:

Grant understood the condition of Lee’s Confederate forces and that Union forces could absorb greater losses.  However, he also understood and loved his troops.  The losses at Cold Harbor were the result of Lee’s troops having the advantage of defence but Lee’s Army could not recover its losses.

The battle of Cold Harbor would become a strategic win for the Union.

————

Please read my books:

1. “55 Rules for a Good Life,” on Amazon (link here).
2. “Our Longest Year in Iraq,” on Amazon (link here).